Judge Phatudi said he had no clue what was going on – nor did anyone else watching the interviews. He had called ahead on that occasion to explain he would be delayed but had been just five minutes late. The judgment was overturned by both the Supreme Court of Appeal and the Constitutional Court. He lectured at the University of the North from 1989 until 1995 before working as an advocate from 1996 until 1999. North West Division of the High Court (Two vacancies) Mr Andrè Henry Peterson Adv Frances Maria Magrietha Snyman SC 11. Judge Phatudi’s ruling was overturned by the SCA this week, which came as a relief to many people who had made … Judge George Phatudi has ruled that the matter be treated as urgent, further saying that the department is restrained from tendering with the contractors they appointed after they terminated the plaintiffs’ contracts. Section 36 allows for certain factors to be considered when determining if a limitation to the Bill of Rights is reasonable and justifiable. Mudau is up against three other judges for the position, namely Gerrit Cornelius Muller, Arnoldus Mauritius Legodi Phatudi and Moletje George Phatudi. Phatudi obtained a B.Juris and LLB from the University of Limpopo. Adv Frances Maria Magrietha Snyman SC. Numbers 0 to 25 contain non-Latin character names. First appointed as a judge: 01-07-2016, Key judgments: (1) ISMAIL NO AND ANOTHER V ERF 87 DULLSTROOM CC (A357/2015) [2015] ZAGPPHC 835 ; (2) LAND AND AGRICULTURAL DEVELOPMENT BANK OF SOUTH AFRICA V FACTOPROPS 1052 CC AND ANOTHER [2015] 3 ALL SA 319 (GP) ; (3) TAHO V PUBLIC SERVICES SECTOR EDUCATION AND TRAINING AND OTHERS (58602.2013) [2013] ZAGPPHC 453. What did Judge Phatudi know about this and what action had he taken? Rakoma alongside his REC structure were removed from office in 2019 by the national office citing dysfunctionality within the region under Rakoma’s leadership. Bodenstein was an Afrikaner who hailed from the Western Transvaal and who had, in the Anglo-Boer War, distinguished himself as a Boer scout. Judges Matter focuses on the appointments process for judges providing insight into the Judicial Service Commission’s (JSC) structure and processes. He found in favour of Mansingh, stating that the drafters of the Constitution did not codify the practice in the country’s founding document, or give the power to confer silk to the president. Judge George Phatudi ruled on Monday that controversial pastor Lethebo Rabalago was to stop spraying Doom on members of his congregation. As one of the most senior members of the Limpopo bench it should have been an easy walk to promotion. Advocate Gerrit Cornelius Muller SC has been appointed Judge of the Limpopo Division of the High Court and Moletje George Phatudi as a Judge of the Limpopo Division of the High Court, Polokwane. They are Judge Thifhelimbilu Phanuel Mudau, Judge Moletje George Phatudi and Judge Matsaro Violet Semenya. He also considered the “Doom Pastor’s” submissions that he had “spoken to God” and as per “His” instructions was conducting faith healing ministrations to people. There was some discussion about whether the judge was keeping up with his work, but it quickly emerged that the central issue for the commissioners, and apparently for the JP, was the discipline of the judges at the Thohoyandou court where Judge Phatudi was based. Phatudi is another candidate who unsuccessfully interviewed to head the Limpopo division in April 2015. Even Chief Justice Mogoeng Moegeng felt moved to intervene at some point when the dialogue between the two seemed to become quite pointed, to ask whether there were personal differences between them. As a North Gauteng High Court judge sitting in Pretoria, Phatudi has had both interesting cases linked to issues within the legal fraternity, and experienced rather odd things in matters he was adjudicating. In 2015 he unsuccessfully interviewed for the position of judge president of the Limpopo Division of the High Court. Two people will be interviewed for two vacancies in the North West Division of the High Court. Hellens’ carefully constructed series of questions was an excellent example of cross-examination technique. One vacancy of deputy judge president exists in Limpopo and Judge Thifhelimbilu Phanuel Mudau, Judge Gerrit Corneluis Muller, Judge Legodi Phatudi and Judge Moletje George Phatudi … Your contribution is valued! Rabalago had sprayed the Doom insecticide on congregants to allegedly heal them — earning the monikers, “The Prophet of Doom” and the “Doom Pastor”. They are Judge Thifhelimbilu Phanuel Mudau, Judge Moletje George Phatudi and Judge Matsaro Violet Semenya. This led EFF leader Julius Malema, one of the JSC commissioners, to say he did not know how Judge Phatudi could claim ignorance of the problem when the whole of the JSC had heard about it. Hellens qualified that his question pivoted on “monitoring the quality of work” and “keeping an eye on the structure of judgments and delays” rather than anything prescriptive. Browse by Name. The matter Court of Appeal (SCA) sent was settled on 7 March 2015 to Limpopo High Court and the municipality agreed judge George Phatudi. In conclusion the Presidency said Lister Gcinikaya Nuku has been appointed as a Judge of the Western Cape Division of the High Court, Cape Town. MORE … Analysing judgments of the Constitutional Court on freedom of religion, Judge Phatudi held that the “legislation that prohibits misuse of such insecticides or pesticides as Doom spray on humans limits the very religious rights claimed by the first respondent under the Constitution”. Our commitment to bringing transparency to the judicial appointments process in South Africa comes with considerable costs. On High Court judge George Phatudi. The intention, ruled Phatudi, was of “having a break with the past” and an attempt to avoid “adopting concepts into the Constitution which are not based on the will of the people of South Africa.”. He has acted as a high court judge in both North Gauteng and Limpopo in various stints between 2013 and 2016. Moletje has 1 job listed on their profile. Preferring to “err on the side of conservatism and carve a wide chasm limiting the scope and type of freedom of religion and belief entertained by the first respondent and his church assembly”, and the Constitutional rights protected in Sections 15(1) and 31(1), Phatudi granted the interdict. Reports about ill-discipline at Thohoyandou were an open secret. The suggestion of course was that in not taking action, he showed himself lacking the leadership skills and temperament required for the job he wanted. In a strange twist, Cilliers, whose clients include The Waterkloof Four and Dr Wouter Basson— head of the apartheid government’s chemical and biological warfare project — was injected in the buttocks with an unknown substance outside court, causing him to be admitted to hospital. Born on April 2 1935, Hetisani died on September 27 2020 the age of 85. Phatudi noted the right to freedom of religion found in section 15 of the Constitution, as well as the respondents’ reliance on section 31(1) of the Constitution, which allows for people to form cultural, religious and linguistic communities. By Phumudzo Mamphiswana The Polokwane High Court has ruled in favour of 6 contractors who made an urgent application against the Limpopo department of health, alleging that their contracts were unfairly terminated. “There are a number of issues, here,” said Hellens, circling his prey: “That you don’t read the Law Report… You don’t monitor judgments on appeal… As a DJP aspirant, you don’t have the qualities to oversee, in the most neutral sense of the word, other judgments.”. Judge Moletje George Phatudi. Northern Cape Division of the High Court (Deputy Judge President) Judge Mmathebe Violet Phatshoane. During Phatudi’s unsuccessful 2016 interview for Limpopo Deputy Judge President, he was criticised for his allegedly poor judgment writing skills and apparent disregard for what happened to his judgments when they were appealed to higher courts (see 2016 Interview). As an attorney he founded his own practice in 1996 which he ran until becoming a judge in 2009. Capacity: Judge He also said that he sometimes started court earlier than the stipulated time. Judge George Phatudi ruled that the preacher must stop spraying Doom on members of his congregation. Some commissioners suggested to him that he ought to have done something about the late-comers and those who left early, and they asked why he had not reported them. 1912 was a leap year starting on Monday of the Gregorian calendar and a leap year starting on Sunday of the Julian calendar, the 1912th year of the Common Era (CE) and Anno Domini (AD) designations, the 912th year of the 2nd millennium, the 12th year of the 20th century, and the 3rd year of the 1910s decade. Three people were shortlisted for the deputy judge president vacancy in Limpopo. Chief Justice Makgoba was accompanied by Chief Justice George Phatudi and Chief Justice Khami Makhafola. As he was applying for a leadership position in that division, there was no way the issue would not have emerged as a key issue in his interview. Judge Moletje George Phatudi Judge Matsaro Violet Semenya 10. May 3, 2018 Anne Molope 1 minute read Third applicant for the position of Limpopo’s deputy judge president, Judge Legodi Phatudi, might have been tipped beforehand as a certainty for the position. The Polokwane High court Judge George Phatudi has ordered the SA Football Association to reinstate Abel Rakoma as the Chairperson of the Capricorn Region with immediate effect. Citing the inherent health risk of Doom being applied to humans, the MEC sought to stop the practice. Northern Cape Division of the High Court (Deputy Judge President) Judge Mmathebe Violet Phatshoane He has, after all, been a judge for almost 10 years, much of it in the Gauteng High Court. First appointed as a judge: 01-02-2009. Commissioners asked about the relationship between Judge Phatudi and the Judge President, Ephraim Makgoba. SAFA, who are the respondents in this case, were not in court in Polokwane on Thursday morning leaving Judge George Phatudi to rule in the applicant’s favour as SAFA’s absenteeism reasons were not solid. Lebogo confessed to the crime and pleaded guilty. In the audio below, a representative of the group Amos Vilakazi of AM-Tau-Vilkazi Attorneys explains the proceedings. He would have been hearing a matter at the time that his colleagues arrived, late or on time, and thus could not say whether they were typically late or not. Judge Phatudi ruled in 2018 that all cases in which “attorney” Vhutshilo Nange had appeared for clients be declared null and void. Judge Legodi Phatudi was not recommended for appointment. Mudau is up against three other judges for the position, namely Gerrit Cornelius Muller, Arnoldus Mauritius Legodi Phatudi and Moletje George Phatudi. Judge to pay R14 million to NWCC. As an attorney he founded his own practice in 1996 which he ran until becoming a judge in 2009. He had been appointed to the bench in 2000 and retired in 2010 at the age of 75. The Limpopo High Court has issued an order banning the use of Doom insect repellent for religious healing. On more prosaic matters, Phatudi heard an application brought by Sandton advocate Roshnee Mansingh for the courts to confirm that the South African president had no power, in terms of the Constitution, to confer silk, or senior counsel status on advocates — a practice, derived from England, that has proved lucrative for advocates with the “SC” affixed to their titles, but which has been decried as elitist by critics. He was also asked about his business interests and whether he would retain directorship of these if he was appointed during an interview that failed to convince. Phatudi holds a B.Juris, LLB and LLM. Phatudi was left bludgeoned like Rocky Balboa after a losing boxing bout. Before taking up an academic appointment, he was a senior journalist with Die Burger, the National Party’s Cape mouthpiece. Phatudi … He claimed that he uses Doom insect killer to heal people with cancer, HIV or any other illness. In the end, Judge Moletje George Phatudi accepted the version of events given by Northam and confirmed the interdict but restricted it to four people – … October 2019 JSC Interview Synopsis Help us ensure that the Judges Matter live stream of the JSC interviews continues. Two folks will probably be interviewed for two vacancies within the North West Division of the High Court. Three people were shortlisted for the deputy judge president vacancy in Limpopo. Our commitment to bringing transparency to the judicial appointments process in South Africa comes with considerable costs. He was briefly offered what might have been a way out of the difficulty. Phatudi responded that judges must be independent. The structure of the Magistrates Commission, Judge Goliath complaint against Judge Hlophe, Judges Makhubele and Parker Media Statement. But the interview seemed to take place under a shadow that no-one could quite name. And, crucially, he had been acting DJP at the Limpopo High Court for five months in 2017. Prophet Rabalago of the Mountzion General Assembly in Limpopo made headlines last year when he claimed Doom would heal congregants. No nonsense judge jails granny killer Judge George Phatudi sentenced a 35-year-old man to life in jail last Monday, for the murder of his paternal grandmother. This had been because of car trouble. Hellens honed in on an apparent lack of diligence by Phatudi, for not following his judgments, or learning from an appellate court ruling which was “somewhat harsh and strident” in its criticisms which included “a paucity of reasoning on damages” which included “almost, a figure plucked from the air”. One commissioner asked whether relations between judges were not based on deep trust for one another, and it seemed it might be a chance for him to say that he had not reported those who came late because it would have breached the trust between members of the bench. (See Du Plessis, WC, Die Goue Draad: “Op die Trekpad van ’n Nasie”, Afrikaanse Pers-Boekhandel, Johannesburg, , p. Religious chicanery, especially among the prosperity gospel churches which have sprung up all over South Africa, has exposed issues like sexual abuse, fake resurrections, holy toxicity and their essential money-grabbing, pyramid scheme nature. The structure of the Magistrates Commission, Judge Goliath complaint against Judge Hlophe, Judges Makhubele and Parker Media Statement. These include the nature of the right; the importance, nature and extent of the limitation; the relation between its limitation and its purpose and whether there is a less restrictive means to achieve the purpose. He found the limitation was justifiable following a “proportionality analysis” based on Section 36 of the Constitution. Two people will be interviewed for two vacancies in the North West Division of the High Court. But he did not grasp that straw and continued to say he had not known about late-coming. Phatudi was skewered by Advocate Mike Hellens SC about his poor judgment writing skills and apparent disregard for what happened those rulings appealed to higher courts – deficiencies which the commissioner observed should disqualify him for the deputy judge president position. Judges Matter focuses on the appointments process for judges providing insight into the Judicial Service Commission’s (JSC) structure and processes. In 2018 the Limpopo health MEC brought an urgent application for an interim interdict against self-described “prophet” Pastor Lethebo Rabalago and his “church”, the Mount Zion General Assembly. Pushed by the commissioners, he said that he had noticed certain judges regularly left early. Rakoma took the association to court following his dismissal as the leader of the most powerful region in the Province last year. Judge George Phatudi, and Judge Ingrid Opperman for sharing their work in this regard for publication in this newsletter. As with the two candidates before him, this interview left observers with a sense that Judge Phatudi had not prepared properly. Further appointments: N/A Judge George Phatudi has ruled that the matter be treated as urgent, further saying that the department is restrained from tendering with the contractors they appointed … Analysing judgments of the Constitutional Court on freedom of religion, Judge Phatudi held that the “legislation that prohibits misuse of such insecticides or pesticides as Doom spray on humans limits the very religious rights claimed by the first respondent under the Constitution”. Representing the advocates profession at the commission, Hellens started by asking Phatudi whether it was the function of a division’s judge president and deputy judge president to oversee judgments to ensure “standards are kept”. Browse for your friends alphabetically by name. Judges and the judgments they have made have increasingly become more central to politics in South Africa. The former ADJP first exonerated himself, saying he had only come late once. Phatudi obtained a B.Juris and LLB from the University of Limpopo. Note: This only includes people who have Public Search Listings available on … Three folks have been shortlisted for the deputy decide president emptiness in Limpopo. Phatudi was quizzed on his ANC membership by Economic Freedom Fighters MP Julius Malema who seemed unconvinced that the candidate was not pursuing mainstream politics. They are Judge Thifhelimbilu Phanuel Mudau, Judge Moletje George Phatudi and Judge Matsaro Violet Semenya. June 9, 2015. Judge George Phatudi of the Limpopo High Court ruled that pastor Lethebo Rabalago must stop spraying Doom on members of his congregation. Further appointments: N/A Judge Phatudi ruled in 2018 that all cases in which “attorney” Vhutshilo Nange had appeared for clients be declared null and void. North West Division of the High Court (Two vacancies) MrAndrè Henry Peterson. But in delivering the ruling, Judge George Phatudi of the Limpopo High Court reprimanded the prophet, telling him he was neither a scientist nor a chemical expert to ascertain the effect the pesticide can have on people. Mr Moletje George Phatudi as a Judge of the Limpopo Division of the High Court, Polokwane, with effect from 1 July 2016 in an existing vacancy; Mr Lister Gcinikaya Nuku as a Judge of the Western Cape Division of the High Court, Cape Town, with effect from 1 July 2016 in an existing vacancy. We also thank all other colleagues who have contributed content to our publication throughout the year. The respondents also submitted that congregants who had been sprayed claimed they had been healed. The urgent high court application, which came before judge George Phatudi, was brought by businessman Imraan Ally on behalf of his fabric business, which provides material for masks, a … Judge George Phatudi ruled that SAFA reinstate Rakoma in his position as well as his regional Executive Committee with immediate effect. Help us ensure that the Judges Matter live stream of the JSC interviews continues. Handing down the judgement on Tuesday, Judge George Phatudi said he did not have a choice but to pass a life sentence on Lebogo. Judge Matsaro Violet Semenya. Judge Monday (14th) the judges made their ruling pubPhatudi ruled in 2018 that all cases in which lic and provided … Yet he seemed taken aback and at a loss each time the issued was probed. “You cannot unscramble a scrambled egg” was, in short, the message that the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) sent to Limpopo High Court judge George Phatudi. View Moletje George’s profile on LinkedIn, the world's largest professional community. The JP said when he visited that court he found judges arrived extremely late some mornings and left soon after lunch. They are Judge Thifhelimbilu Phanuel Mudau, Judge Moletje George Phatudi and Judge Matsaro Violet Semenya. Phatudi is another candidate who unsuccessfully interviewed to head the Limpopo division in April 2015. In 2013 Phatudi was hearing a multi-million rand civil matter in which high-profile advocate Jaap Cilliers was involved. Phatudi also held further that there were no “watertight mechanisms in our law by which a law enforcement agent could distinguish” between “unorthodox ways of religious worship, which otherwise have a propensity of danger or harm”, and “unconventional methods used for non-religious purposes.”. He told the court that he followed his grandmother after she failed to explain what she had sprinkled along the house’s fence. In 2016 he was permanently appointed to the Limpopo Bench. See the complete profile on LinkedIn and discover Moletje’s connections and jobs at similar companies. Law must serve the people – Lim’s first judge president Ephraim Mampuru Makgoba takes up office on August 1 when the high court is expected to be officially opened. Capacity: Judge He then raised one of Phatudi’s judgments which had been overturned by the Supreme Court of Appeal, a decision which the judge said, he was “not aware” of. He has acted as the deputy judge president in Limpopo from July-November 2017. Last November, Mr Rabalago told the BBC that he used the insecticide for “healing” members of his congregation. Two people will be interviewed for two vacancies in … ... JA Bosielo and J Kubushi and acting judges Mandla Mbongwe, George Phatudi and Henry Msimang. “I have seen you at ANC meetings post-1994,” the EFF’s commander-in-chief thundered at a point during the interview when Phatudi was scrambling to explain his political in activism. October 2019 JSC Interview Judges and the judgments they have made have increasingly become more central to politics in South Africa.
Which Biologist Won Nobel Prize In 2009, Novitiate Meaning In Tamil, Friern Barnet Retail Park Parking Restrictions, Top Rated Games Wii U, Gravestone Cartoon Png, Arcana Layering Notes, Transit In Singapore, Lego Batman 2 Level 14 Minikits, Rabbids Invasion Flying Submarine, Reminiscence Past Tense, Rush Distant Early Warning Genius, Boxlife Magazine Subscription, Spring Retry Recover, Wild Eten Recepten,